Review Summary
If you’ve been told your reflux is caused by too much stomach acid, Why Stomach Acid is Good for You might change the way you look at digestion forever. This book doesn’t just challenge the mainstream approach—it flips it completely. Dr. Jonathan Wright argues that most reflux and indigestion symptoms are caused by low stomach acid, not too much.
And that the real danger of long-term reflux isn’t acid at all—it’s what happens when digestion stops working the way it should. The book makes a strong, science-backed case for healing from the root, not just masking symptoms. It’s not a breezy read, and the anti-pharma tone won’t be for everyone—but the depth of insight here could be a turning point for many.
✅ Pros
- Challenges the “too much acid” myth
- Shows why stomach acid matters
- Offers practical, low-cost natural fixes
- Grounded in real cases and decades of experience
❌ Cons
- Can overwhelm those who are less technical
- Requires reader initiative to deeply understand
- Bold anti-pharma tone may distract some readers
Table of Contents
My Full Review
Wright’s thesis is simple but controversial: most people with reflux, bloating, or “acid indigestion” actually don’t have enough acid. And because acid triggers a cascade of digestive events—from breaking down proteins to signaling enzyme release—when it’s low, everything downstream falls apart.
He walks through how this leads to poor absorption of key nutrients like iron, calcium, magnesium, B12, and zinc—nutrients that reflux sufferers are often deficient in. Without them, healing stalls, and symptoms expand beyond the gut.
Even more compelling: he shows how this low-acid state creates the perfect environment for harmful bacteria to thrive. The stomach’s acid isn’t just for digestion—it’s also our first line of defense against infections. When it’s suppressed, we become more vulnerable to everything from H. pylori to small intestinal bacterial overgrowth (SIBO).
The book also explores how low acid increases gas and fermentation, which can put pressure on the lower esophageal sphincter (LES) and trigger reflux—not because acid is too high, but because digestion isn’t progressing the way it should.
Wright argues that the real solution isn’t symptom suppression—it’s restoring healthy stomach function. That means understanding the chain reaction of digestion and supporting the body with what it needs to do its job naturally, instead of shutting it down with acid blockers.
Unlike my read of Dropping Acid by Jamie Koufman, I found myself taking notes on nearly every other page—this book is packed with meaningful science-backed insights that help you truly understand what’s going on in your body.
What’s Actually Useful
This book isn’t light reading—but if you’re ready to dig deeper, it really delivers. Unlike quick-fix guides, Why Stomach Acid is Good for You offers a root-cause perspective that challenges the typical reflux advice. Here’s what stood out as truly helpful, especially if you’re looking to heal—not just manage—your symptoms:
✅ Challenges the “too much acid” myth
At its core, this book invites readers to reconsider one of the most common reflux assumptions: that the problem is too much acid. Dr. Wright presents decades of evidence showing that low stomach acid is far more common—and often the real root cause of reflux symptoms. This reframe is compelling, powerful, and can shift your entire approach to healing.
✅ Shows why stomach acid matters
Wright walks through the essential jobs that stomach acid performs: breaking down protein, absorbing minerals and vitamins, sterilizing the stomach, and triggering the next stages of digestion. Without it, the whole system stalls—and you start seeing not just reflux, but fatigue, skin issues, nutrient deficiencies, other named diseases, and more. He connects these dots clearly and convincingly.
✅ Offers practical, low-cost natural fixes
One of the most empowering parts of the book is Wright’s treatment roadmap. It’s not about fancy protocols or expensive testing. He gives readers simple tools: betaine HCl, pepsin, bitters, zinc, DGL, probiotics—and explains how to use them to rebuild digestion. For many, these low-cost interventions can lead to real, lasting relief.
✅ Grounded in real cases and decades of experience
This isn’t a theoretical book. Wright shares patient stories, case studies, and observations from decades in clinical practice. The anecdotes are relatable, and the outcomes often mirror what many reflux sufferers have experienced themselves—symptoms that didn’t respond to meds, but improved dramatically with digestive support.
Where the Book Misses the Mark
❌ Can be overwhelming for those who are less technical
This isn’t a “digestive health for beginners” book. It dives into physiology, hormone signaling, acid production mechanisms, and even neurotransmitter pathways. If you’re new to this space, you may need to reread sections—or Google terms as you go.
❌ Requires reader initiative to deeply understand
There’s a ton of value here, but you won’t find step-by-step protocols, summary charts, or “start here” boxes. Instead, you’ll need to synthesize what you’re reading, take notes, and possibly work with a practitioner to apply it.
❌ Bold anti-pharma tone may distract some readers
Wright doesn’t hold back in his critique of the pharmaceutical industry or the FDA. While some readers will appreciate the candor, others may find the tone confrontational or overly political. It doesn’t take away from the science—but it might pull focus from the practical advice.
Summary of Key Recommendations
Here’s a snapshot of what Dr. Wright recommends for healing from low stomach acid:
- Test your acid levels: Ideally with the Heidelberg capsule, or try the baking soda burp test at home
- Replace what’s missing: Integrate vitamins and re-acidify with meals, gradually increasing as tolerated
- Support healing: Use DGL, glutamine, zinc, and vitamin A to strengthen the stomach lining
- Restore balance: Add probiotics and consider mastic gum or other antimicrobials if bacterial overgrowth is suspected
- Avoid suppressors: Cut out PPIs, calcium carbonate, and high-dose antacids if safe to do so
- Use bitters wisely: Gentian, wormwood, and artemisia can help—but only if tasted, not swallowed quickly
It’s not a one-size-fits-all plan—but it’s a powerful starting point for rebuilding digestion from the ground up.
Final Thoughts on Why Stomach Acid Is Good For You
Why Stomach Acid is Good for You isn’t just another reflux book—it’s a challenge to everything we’ve been taught about digestive health. It invites you to stop fearing stomach acid and start asking why your body isn’t producing enough of it in the first place.
This book won’t offer quick fixes or flashy lists. But if you’re feeling stuck and your symptoms are piling up instead of going away—this book may help you shift directions toward healing.
Bottom line: Your body isn’t deficient in drugs so adding them isn’t going to fix the problem! That said, your body is deficient in certain things and it might just need your help with restoring what’s been missing all along.
Why Stomach Acid is Good for You is one of the better reflux books out there, but if you’re interested in a book that incorporates this information and more, check out How I Cured My Silent Reflux.
This content is for informational purposes only and is not medical advice. Consult your physician for personalized care.
This free site uses affiliate links. If it's helpful, consider purchasing using the product links —I earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
